Why was NYSE-Frankfurt stock exchange merger blocked?

PDF | Print | E-mail

Share on facebook
Why was NYSE-Frankfurt stock exchange merger blocked?

NEW YORK (CNNMoney) -- The parent company of the New York Stock Exchange said Wednesday that it plans to end its proposed merger with the parent of the Frankfurt exchange, after European officials blocked the deal.

NYSE Euronext (NYX, Fortune 500) said it will instead repurchase shares, as a way to bolster value to investors once the agreement with Deutsche Boerse is officially terminated.

"We proposed significant and tangible remedies designed to address the European Commission's concerns with the transaction," NYSE Euronext chairman Jan-Michiel Hessels said in a statement.

But, he added, "we would not agree to any concessions that would undermine or compromise the industrial and economic logic of the proposed combination."

The European Commission said it prohibited the merger on the basis that it would stifled competition by creating a "quasi-monopoly in the area of European financial derivatives traded globally on exchanges."

The EC said the two exchanges already control more than 90% of global trade in European derivatives.

Hessels said he "strongly" disagrees with the EC's decision, noting that it is "based on a fundamentally different understanding of the derivatives market."

Europe's debt crisis: Where things stand

NYSE Euronext said that it planned to resume its $550 million share repurchase program after the release of its fourth quarter and 2011 results on Feb. 10.

But the $64,000 question is, where does the NYSE go from here?

"They had a lot to gain from this merger," said Peter Lenardos, director of European diversified financials for RBC Capital Markets in London. A tie-up with Deutsche Boerse would have given NYSE Euronext a more diverse revenue stream, stronger balance sheet, stronger growth rate and higher margins.

This is the third big global exchange deal to go bust over the past year, and it's unlikely an other suitor will emerger. The Australian and Singapore exchanges scrapped their merger plans last April, and the Toronto and London Stock Exchanges called it quits in June.

Last year, Nasdaq and the IntercontinentalExchange withdrew their hostile bid for NYSE Euronext after the Justice Department said it would block a three-way merger.

ICE declined to comment and Nasdaq didn't immediately return a request for comment.

With a big M&A deal unlikely, NYSE Euronext should consider a smaller acqusition to diversify its business, said Lenardos.

"I'm not saying the business is broken, but the headwinds are very, very real," he said. "On a competitive basis globally, there are others that are better positioned."

sourse: 

http://money.cnn.com/2012/02/01/markets/nyse_euronext_deutsche_boerse/?source=cnn_bin

Facebook Comments

Stockwatch

Loading
Chart
o Lentuo International 1.96 ▼0.08 (-3.92%)
o Yandex 20.47 ▼0.53 (-2.52%)
o DISCB 48.37 ▼0.71 (-1.45%)
o LinkedIn 99.02 ▼5.93 (-5.65%)
o Zipcar Inc 9.20 ▼0.47 (-4.86%)
o Melco Crown Ent.Ltd 12.06 ▲0.12 (1.01%)
o Qihoo 360 Tech. 20.88 ▲0.24 (1.16%)
o Canon Inc. 41.37 ▼0.55 (-1.31%)
o Herbalife Ltd. 44.76 ▲0.18 (0.40%)
NYSE:LAS

Lentuo International

Company ID [NYSE:LAS] Last trade:1.96 Trade time:4:02PM EDT Value change:▼0.08 (-3.92%)
Nasdaq:YNDX

Yandex

Company ID [Nasdaq:YNDX] Last trade:20.47 Trade time:3:59PM EDT Value change:▼0.53 (-2.52%)
Nasdaq:DISCA

DISCB

Company ID [Nasdaq:DISCA] Last trade:48.37 Trade time:4:00PM EDT Value change:▼0.71 (-1.45%)
NYSE:LNKD

LinkedIn

Company ID [NYSE:LNKD] Last trade:99.02 Trade time:4:05PM EDT Value change:▼5.93 (-5.65%)
Nasdaq:ZIP

Zipcar Inc

Company ID [Nasdaq:ZIP] Last trade:9.20 Trade time:3:59PM EDT Value change:▼0.47 (-4.86%)
Nasdaq:MPEL

Melco Crown Ent.Ltd

Company ID [Nasdaq:MPEL] Last trade:12.06 Trade time:4:00PM EDT Value change:▲0.12 (1.01%)
NYSE:QIHU

Qihoo 360 Tech.

Company ID [NYSE:QIHU] Last trade:20.88 Trade time:4:07PM EDT Value change:▲0.24 (1.16%)
NYSE:CAJ

Canon Inc.

Company ID [NYSE:CAJ] Last trade:41.37 Trade time:4:00PM EDT Value change:▼0.55 (-1.31%)
NYSE:HLF

Herbalife Ltd.

Company ID [NYSE:HLF] Last trade:44.76 Trade time:4:04PM EDT Value change:▲0.18 (0.40%)

What's New on Little Skylark Blog

LittleSkylark - Multilingual Financial Services
Multilingual financial Newsletter
  • Shares of “Gazprom” back in 2009
    Read online Lenta.ru yesterday 12:45
  • Russia is among the fastest growing markets for luxury goods
    Read online Lenta.ru yesterday 09:00 Photo: TRC” TERRA » Russia, India and China proved to be the fastest-growing luxury markets in the world. The rate of growth of sales of luxury goods in those countries are held at the level of 15-20 percent per year. This was in the room from May 18, the newspaper “Vedomosti” referring to the report of the consulting company Bain & Company. According to the report, in 2009 the Russian market for luxury goods declined [...]
  • Manufacturer of cars going to build a subway in Moscow
    Read online Lenta.ru yesterday 11:34 Photo: Lenta.ru co-owner of the largest manufacturer of cars in Russia – “Transmashholding” – Andrew Bokarev began negotiating the purchase of the main contractor for the construction of the Moscow Metro – “Mosmetrostroy.” This was in the room from May 18, the newspaper “Vedomosti”, citing sources familiar with the negotiations. Now “Transmashholding” is not engaged in construction. The company will cooperate with the City of Moscow in another area – up to 2020 the government [...]

Adverts

Highlights

Share on facebook

All rights reserved. © Copyright 2011 Skylark, Inc. | Disclaimer